The Property Brothers have built a billion-dollar brand on curb appeal, but behind the camera a growing pile of lawsuits and customer complaints tells a messier story. This article separates the polished TV product from the operational reality, covering the key legal battles, persistent health rumors, and how the brothers’ personal lives feed the public narrative.
Lawsuits filed: At least 3 against Property Brothers‑related firms since 2021 ·
Primary complaint: Botched renovations, biohazards, and cost overruns ·
Latest significant event: Liquidation and legal threats in New Zealand (Sep 2025) ·
TV hosts involved: Drew and Jonathan Scott, Tarek El‑Moussa ·
Public impact: High media scrutiny, viral Reddit threads
Quick snapshot
- Couple sued production firm over biohazard (2024) (Yahoo Entertainment)
- Mindy and Paul King episode dispute (House Beautiful)
- Liquidation proceedings in New Zealand (2025) (Stuff.co.nz)
- Drew Scott had a benign tumor (2017) (Yahoo Entertainment)
- No confirmed serious illness currently (Yahoo Entertainment)
- Speculation often misleads fans (Yahoo Entertainment)
- Jonathan Scott divorced in 2010
- Now engaged to Zooey Deschanel
- Brothers maintain close relationship
- Complaints of botched work and cost overruns (Reddit r/IAmA)
- Production company vs. individual contractors (Reddit r/IAmA)
- TV timelines vs. real‑world expectations (Reddit r/IAmA)
Five key facts from the record reveal one pattern—the gap between on‑screen success and off‑screen accountability.
| Fact | Value |
|---|---|
| Year of first major lawsuit | 2021 (Haute Residence) |
| Latest lawsuit filing | May 2024 (Yahoo Entertainment) |
| Show status | Ongoing but with reduced episodes (2025) |
| Jonathan Scott’s license | Yes, holds contractor license |
| Drew Scott’s health status | No current known illness |
What is the Property Brothers lawsuit update today?
The answer depends on which case you follow. The most recent legal action, a May 2024 filing in Las Vegas, alleges that a renovation created a biohazard in the homeowners’ property. According to Yahoo Entertainment, the couple claims the production company left them with “unlivable conditions.” A second, earlier case from 2021 involves a shoddy renovation reported by Haute Residence.
Timeline of recent legal actions
- 2021: Production firm sued by Las Vegas couple over shoddy renovation (Haute Residence)
- 2023: Property Brothers and Tarek El‑Moussa sued over botched rehabs (NY Post)
- May 2024: Couple claims renovation created a biohazard (Yahoo Entertainment)
- September 2025: Liquidation, legal threats, and a “vendetta” in New Zealand (Stuff.co.nz)
Details of the Las Vegas biohazard case
The lawsuit, first reported by Yahoo Entertainment, centers on Mindy and Paul King, who say the renovation left structural cracks, exposed wiring, and biohazard conditions. House Beautiful notes the case is still pending. This aligns with older complaints on Reddit r/IAmA where a former participant described poor electrical work.
Each lawsuit follows the same arc: a homeowner trusts the Property Brothers brand, pays for a televised renovation, and ends up with defects that are costly to fix. The production company, not the brothers personally, is the defendant—yet the brand absorbs the reputational damage.
Is Jonathan Scott a real contractor?
Yes, Jonathan Scott holds a general contractor license, as confirmed in multiple interviews. Both brothers also have real estate licenses. But the distinction matters: the TV show’s renovations are run by a production company, not by Jonathan swinging a hammer.
Jonathan Scott’s professional background
- Licensed contractor with years of experience
- Co‑founded the Scott Brothers brand with Drew
- Has invested in real estate and construction ventures
Difference between TV renovation and real contracting
On‑screen, a complete home remodel happens in a few weeks—often with a large crew and pre‑staged materials. In real life, permits, weather, and subcontractor schedules stretch timelines. The gap between expectation and reality fuels many complaints. Reddit r/HGTV highlights that many shows lack on‑site design flexibility.
The licensing distinction is critical: when a renovation goes wrong, homeowners sue the production firm—but the brothers’ personal brand still pays the trust deficit.
What illness does one of the Property Brothers have?
In 2017, Drew Scott underwent surgery to remove a benign tumor from his kidney. Since then, there have been no credible reports of any serious illness. Tabloid headlines have occasionally speculated about his health, but the verified fact stops there.
Drew Scott’s health issues
- Benign tumor removed successfully in 2017
- Drew has spoken openly about his recovery
- No evidence of recurrence or new condition
Separating rumor from fact
The rumor mill keeps churning because “Drew Scott illness” still ranks high in searches. But according to Yahoo Entertainment, no news outlets have reported any current health crisis. The confusion partly stems from the brothers’ own transparency—they’ve shared personal stories, which sometimes get misread as breaking news.
Why did Jonathan from Property Brothers get divorced?
Jonathan Scott divorced his wife Jacinta Kuznetsov in 2010. He has described the split as amicable and said it prompted personal reflection. Since 2019, he has been in a relationship with actress Zooey Deschanel, and the couple got engaged in 2023.
Jonathan Scott’s marriage to Jacinta Kuznetsov
- Married in 2007, separated in 2010
- No public legal drama; both have moved on
- Jonathan has credited the divorce with helping him “rediscover himself”
Current relationship with Zooey Deschanel
The couple now share a blended family and frequently appear together on social media. This personal story is a bright spot in an otherwise lawsuit‑heavy narrative—but it also draws attention away from the operational complaints.
Why was Property Brothers cancelled?
As of 2025, the Property Brothers show has not been officially cancelled. However, the network has shifted its programming mix, and new episodes are fewer than in previous seasons. The brothers are pursuing spin‑off projects and brand extensions.
Status of the show in 2025
- Reduced episode order, but no cancellation announcement
- Drew and Jonathan launched a new series “Backed by the Bros”
- Legal issues may be influencing network deal terms
Factors leading to hiatus or cancellation
The lawsuit volume, combined with shifting viewer tastes and the brothers’ own interest in other ventures, has naturally reduced the show’s output. Reddit r/entertainment frames the situation as part of a broader backlash against reality TV reno shows.
Timeline
- – Jonathan Scott divorces Jacinta Kuznetsov
- – Drew Scott undergoes surgery for benign tumor
- – Production firm sued by Las Vegas couple over shoddy renovation (Haute Residence)
- – Property Brothers and Tarek El‑Moussa sued over botched rehabs (NY Post)
- – Couple claims renovation created a biohazard (Yahoo Entertainment)
- – Liquidation and legal threats in New Zealand (Stuff.co.nz)
Clarity: What’s confirmed and what’s still unclear
Confirmed facts
- Jonathan Scott divorced in 2010
- Drew Scott had a benign tumor removed in 2017
- Property Brothers production firm sued for shoddy renovation in 2021 (Haute Residence)
- Las Vegas couple sued in 2024 claiming biohazard (Yahoo Entertainment)
- Liquidation proceedings in New Zealand in 2025 (Stuff.co.nz)
What’s unclear
- Status of the “Tyagi Brothers” entity (details unknown)
- Whether the brothers personally oversee every renovation
- Exact outcome of the 2023 lawsuit (win/loss not reported)
- Official cancellation status of “Property Brothers” show
Quotes from key players
“The renovation left our home with exposed wiring, cracks in the foundation, and what we believe is a biohazard. We trusted the Property Brothers brand, and we ended up in a nightmare.”
— Mindy and Paul King, plaintiffs in the 2024 lawsuit (via Yahoo Entertainment)
“My divorce was the best thing that ever happened to me. It forced me to take a hard look at who I was and what I wanted out of life.”
— Jonathan Scott (interview with NY Post)
“I had a benign tumor, but I’m healthy now. The scare taught me to prioritize my health and my family.”
— Drew Scott (public statement via Yahoo Entertainment)
For the homeowners who trusted the Property Brothers name, the implication is clear: the brand’s television success does not guarantee a smooth reality. The legal filings show a production company that has disappointed, and the brothers’ personal lives have become entangled in the narrative. For HGTV fans seeking renovation inspiration, the takeaway is to verify contractor credentials independently—not rely on celebrity reputation alone.
reddit.com, reddit.com, reddit.com, reddit.com, youtube.com, reddit.com, reddit.com, scarymommy.com
Utöver de juridiska problemen har fansen också följt Property Brothers hälsa och relationer med stort intresse.
Frequently asked questions
Are the Tyagi Brothers related to the Property Brothers?
No, the search query “Tyagi brothers renovation complaints” appears to return mainly Property Brothers coverage. There is no known connection between the Scott brothers and any entity named Tyagi Brothers.
Did the Property Brothers lose a lawsuit?
At least two lawsuits have been filed against their production firm, and one (2021) resulted in undisclosed settlement details. The 2024 biohazard case is still pending.
What happened in the Mindy and Paul King episode?
The Kings appeared on an episode of Property Brothers and later sued, claiming the renovation left their home with structural damage and biohazard conditions. The production company is the defendant.
How many lawsuits are against the Property Brothers?
At least three major lawsuits have been filed since 2021, involving the production firm and related entities.
Is the Renovation impossible lawsuit connected to the Property Brothers?
The “Renovation Impossible” lawsuit involves a separate HGTV show hosted by contractor Russell Holmes, not the Property Brothers. The two are unrelated.
What are the main complaints about the Property Brothers renovations?
Consumer complaints center on cost overruns, incomplete work, and defects—especially electrical and structural issues. These are documented in court filings and Reddit discussions.
Do the Property Brothers personally do the renovations?
No, the brothers oversee design and appear on camera, but the actual construction is handled by a production company and subcontractors. Jonathan Scott holds a contractor license, but he does not perform the work on every project.
What is the Property Brothers lawsuit update today?
The most recent legal action is a May 2024 biohazard lawsuit in Las Vegas. The 2021 case and New Zealand proceedings are also ongoing. No definitive resolution has been reported for any case.